| The importance of tropical tree-ring chronologies for global change research | |
Groenendijk, Peter; Babst, Flurin1; Trouet, Valerie3; Fan, Ze-Xin ; Granato-Souza, Daniela; Locosselli, Giuliano Maselli7; Mokria, Mulugeta8,9; Panthi, Shankar; Pumijumnong, Nathsuda10; Abiyu, Abrham11; Acuna-Soto, Rodolfo; Adenesky-Filho, Eduardo; Alfaro-Sanchez, Raquel; Anholetto Junior, Claudio Roberto17; Vieira Aragao, Jose Roberto18; Assis-Pereira, Gabriel; Astudillo-Sanchez, Claudia C.; Barbosa, Ana Carolina22; Barreto, Nathan de Oliveira; Battipaglia, Giovanna23; Beeckman, Hans24; Botosso, Paulo Cesar25; Bourland, Nils24; Brauning, Achim8; Brienen, Roel26; Brookhouse, Matthew27; Buajan, Supaporn10; Buckley, Brendan M.; Julio Camarero, J.; Carrillo-Parra, Artemio; Ceccantini, Gregorio; Centeno-Erguera, Librado R.; Cerano-Paredes, Julian; Cervantes-Martinez, Rosalinda; Chanthorn, Wirong33; Chen, Ya-Jun; Cintra, Bruno Barcante Ladvocat34,35; Heriberto Cornejo-Oviedo, Eladio; Cortes-Cortes, Otoniel; Costa, Clayane Matos36; Couralet, Camille24; Bianca Crispin-DelaCruz, Doris; D'Arrigo, Rosanne; David, Diego A.; De Ridder, Maaike24; Del Valle, Jorge Ignacio; Diaz-Carrillo, Oscar A.; Dobner, Mario, Jr.; Doucet, Jean-Louis; Dunisch, Oliver41; Enquist, Brian J.; Esemann-Quadros, Karin; Esquivel-Arriaga, Gerardo; Fayolle, Adeline46,47; Bergamo Fenilli, Tatiele Anete14; Eugenia Ferrero, M.; Fichtler, Esther49; Finnegan, Patrick M.; Fontana, Claudia; Francisco, Kainana S.; Fu, Pei-Li; Galvao, Franklin; Gebrekirstos, Aster9; Giraldo, Jorge A.; Gloor, Emanuel26; Godoy-Veiga, Milena; Guerra, Anthony54; Haneca, Kristof55; Harley, Grant Logan56; Heinrich, Ingo57,58; Helle, Gerhard59; Ciro Hernandez-Diaz, Jose; Hornink, Bruna; Hubau, Wannes60; Inga, Janet G.; Islam, Mahmuda61,62; Jiang, Yu-Mei; Kaib, Mark64; Khamisi, Zakia Hassan; Koprowski, Marcin65,66; Layme, Eva67; Joshua Leffler, A.; Ligot, Gauthier40; Lisi, Claudio Sergio36; Loader, Neil J.; Lobo, Francisco de Almeida70; Longhi-Santos, Tomaz; Lopez, Lidio48; Lopez-Hernandez, Maria I.; Penetra Cerveira Lousada, Jose Luis72; Manzanedo, Ruben D.; Marcon, Amanda K.; Maxwell, Justin T.; Mendivelso, Hooz A.; Mendoza-Villa, Omar N.; Nunes Menezes, Itallo Romany36,78; Montoia, Valdinez Ribeiro79; Moors, Eddy80,81; Moreno, Miyer82; Angel Muniz-Castro, Miguel; Nabais, Cristina84; Nathalang, Anuttara85,86; Ngoma, Justine86; Nogueira, Francisco de Carvalho, Jr.; Oliveira, Juliano Morales87,88; Olmedo, Gabriela Morais89; Ortega-Rodriguez, Daigard Ricardo; Rodriguez Ortiz, Carmen Eugenia90; Pagotto, Mariana Alves36; Paredes-Villanueva, Kathelyn; Perez-De-Lis, Gonzalo; Ponce Calderon, Laura Patricia94; Armando Portal-Cahuana, Leif; Alexander Pucha-Cofrep, Darwin; Quadri, Paulo97; Rahman, Mizanur61; Andres Ramirez, Jorge98; Jimmy Requena-Rojas, Edilson; Reyes-Flores, Judith; Ribeiro, Adauto de Souza36; Robertson, Iain69; Alejandro Roig, Fidel48,99; Roquette, Jose Guilherme100; Alonso Rubio-Camacho, Ernesto; Sanchez-Salguero, Raul; Sass-Klaassen, Ute; Schongart, Jochen105; Scipioni, Marcelo Callegari39; Sheppard, Paul R.; Silva, Lucas C. R.; Slotta, Franziska107; Soria-Diaz, Leroy; Sousa, Luciana K. V. S.; Speer, James H.; Therrell, Matthew D.; Ticse-Otarola, Ginette; Tomazello-Filho, Mario; Torbenson, Max C. A.; Tor-Ngern, Pantana; Touchan, Ramzi2; Van den Bulcke, Jan60; Vazquez-Selem, Lorenzo; Velazquez-Perez, Adin H.; Venegas-Gonzalez, Alejandro; Villalba, Ricardo48; Villanueva-Diaz, Jose; Vlam, Mart104; Vourlitis, George119; Wehenkel, Christian30; Wils, Tommy120,121; Zavaleta, Erika S.; Zewdu, Eshetu Asfaw123; Zhang, Yong-Jiang; Zhou, Zhe-Kun; Zuidema, Pieter A.
| |
| 2025 | |
| Source Publication | QUATERNARY SCIENCE REVIEWS
 |
| ISSN | 0277-3791 |
| Volume | 355Issue:xPages:- |
| Abstract | Tropical forests and woodlands are key components of the global carbon and water cycles. Yet, how climate change affects these biogeochemical cycles is poorly understood because of scarce long-term observations of tropical tree growth. The recent rise in tropical tree-ring studies may help to fill this gap, but a large-scale quantitative analysis of their potential in global change research is missing. We compiled a list of all tropical tree species known to form annual tree rings and built a network encompassing 492 tropical ring-width chronologies to evaluate the potential to generate insights on climate sensitivity of woody productivity and to build centuries-long reconstructions of climate variability. We assess chronology quality, length, and climatic representativeness and explore how these change along climatic gradients. Finally, we applied species-distribution modeling to identify regions with potential for tree-ring studies in ecological and climatic studies. The number of tropical chronologies has rapidly increased, with similar to 400 added over the past two decades. Yet, tree-ring studies are biased towards high-elevation locations, with gaps in warmer and wetter climates, on the African continent, and for angiosperm species. The longest chronologies with strongest climate signals (i.e., synchronous growth variations among trees) are from cool regions. In wet regions, climate signals and precipitation sensitivity decrease. Most tropical regions harbor 5-15 (and up to 80) species with proven potential to generate chronologies. The potential for long climate reconstructions is particularly high in drier high elevation sites. Our findings support strategies to effectively expand tree-ring research in the tropics, by targeting specific species and regions. Tropical dendrochronology can importantly contribute to global change research by generating historical context of climate extremes, quantifying climate sensitivity of woody productivity and benchmarking vegetation models. |
| Keyword | Climate sensitivity Growth synchrony Pantropical tree growth Dendrochronology |
| Subject Area | Physical Geography ; Geology |
| DOI | 10.1016/j.quascirev.2025.109233 |
| Indexed By | SCI |
| Language | 英语 |
| WOS ID | WOS:001458692000001 |
| Citation statistics | |
| Document Type | 期刊论文 |
| Identifier | https://ir.xtbg.ac.cn/handle/353005/14660 |
| Collection | 2012年后新成立研究组 |
| Affiliation | 1.Univ Campinas UNICAMP, Inst Biol, Dept Plant Biol, POB 6109, BR-13083970 Campinas, SP, Brazil 2.Univ Arizona, Sch Nat Resources & Environm, Tucson, AZ USA 3.Univ Arizona, Tree Ring Res Lab, Tucson, AZ USA 4.Belgian Climate Ctr, Ringlaan 3, B-1090 Uccle, Belgium 5.Chinese Acad Sci, Xishuangbanna Trop Bot Garden, CAS Key Lab Trop Forest Ecol, Mengla 666303, Yunnan, Peoples R China 6.Alabama A&M Univ, Forestry Ecol & Wildlife Program, Nat Resources & Environm Sci Dept, Normal, AL 35762 USA 7.Univ Sao Paulo, Inst Biosci, Dept Bot, R Matao 277, BR-05508090 Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil 8.Univ Sao Paulo, Ctr Nucl Energy Agr, Ave Centenario 303, BR-13416000 Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil 9.Friedrich Alexander Univ Erlangen Nuremberg, Inst Geog, Wetterkreuz 15, D-91058 Erlangen, Germany 10.World Agroforestry Ctr ICRAF, United Nations Ave,POB 30677-00100, Nairobi, Kenya 11.Mahidol Univ, Fac Environm & Resource studies, 999 Phutthamonthon Rd4, Phutthamonthon 73170, Nakhon Pathom, Thailand 12.World Agroforestry Ctr ICRAF, CO ILRI Campus,POB 5689, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia 13.Univ Nacl Autonoma Mexico, Dept Microbiol & Parasitol, Mexico City, DF, Mexico 14.Univ Nacl Autonoma Mexico, Fac Filosofia & Letras, Colegio Geog, Mexico City, DF, Mexico 15.Univ Reg Blumenau, Dept Forest Engn, R Sao Paulo 3366, BR-89030000 Itoupava Seca, SC, Brazil 16.Nat Resources Canada, Northern Forestry Ctr, Canadian Forest Serv, 5320 122 St NW, Edmonton, AB T6H 3S5, Canada 17.Wilfrid Laurier Univ, Dept Biol, 75 Univ Ave W, Waterloo, ON N2L 3C5, Canada 18.Mamiraua Inst Sustainable Dev, Forest Management Program, Tefe, Brazil 19.Fed Univ Ceara UFC, Dept Plant Biol, Ave Mister Hull S-N PICI Campus, BR-60440900 Fortaleza, Ceara, Brazil 20.Univ Sao Paulo, Dept Forest Sci, Luiz de Queiroz Coll Agr, Ave Padua Dias 11, BR-13418900 Piracicaba, SP, Brazil 21.Inst Pesquisas Ambientais Estado Sao Paulo, Assis, SP, Brazil 22.Astudillo-Sanchez, Claudia C.] Univ Autonoma Tamaulipas, Fac Ingn & Ciencias, Ciudad Victoria 87149, Tamaulipas, Mexico 23.Univ Fed Lavras, Dept Forest Sci, Tree Ring Lab, BR-37200900 Lavras, MG, Brazil 24.Univ Campania L Vanvitelli, Dept Environm Biol & Pharmaceut Sci & Technol, Via Vivaldi 43, I-81100 Caserta, Italy 25.Royal Museum Cent Africa, Wood Biol Serv, Leuvense Steenweg 13, B-3080 Tervuren, Belgium 26.Brazilian Agr Res Corp Embrapa, Embrapa Forestry, Estrada Ribeira Km 111, BR-83411000 Colombo, PR, Brazil 27.Univ Leeds, Sch Geog, Leeds LS2 9JT, W Yorkshire, England 28.Australian Natl Univ, Fenner Sch Environm & Soc, Canberra, ACT, Australia 29.Columbia Univ, Lamont Doherty Earth Observ, Palisades, NY USA 30.Julio Camarero, J.] CSIC, Inst Pirenaico Ecol IPE, E-50192 Zaragoza, Spain 31.Univ Juarez Estado Durango, Inst Silvicultura & Ind Madera, Durango 34120, Mexico 32.Ctr Nacl Invest Disciplinaria Relac Agua Suelo Pl, Inst Nacl Invest Forest Agr & Pecuarias INIFAP, Margen Derecha Canal Sacramento Km 6-5, Durango 35140, Mexico 33.Univ Autonoma Agraria Antonio Narro, Dept Forestal, Calzada Antonio Narro 1923, Saltillo 25315, Coahuila, Mexico 34.Kasetsart Univ, Fac Environm, Dept Environm Technol & Management, 50 Ngamwongwan Rd, Bangkok 10900, Thailand 35.Univ Birmingham, Sch Geog Earth & Environm Sci, Birmingham, W Midlands, England 36.Univ Birmingham, Birmingham Inst Forest Res, Birmingham, W Midlands, England 37.Univ Fed Sergipe UFS, Dept Biol, Lab Plant Anat & Dendrochronol, BR-49100000 Aracaju, SE, Brazil 38.Univ Continental, Lab Dendrocronol, Ave San Carlos 1980, Huancayo, Peru 39.David, Diego A.] Univ Nacl Colombia, Dept Forest Sci, Sede Medellin, Medellin, Colombia 40.Univ Fed Santa Catarina UFSC, Dept Agr Biodiversidade & Florestas, Curitibanos, SC, Brazil 41.Univ Liege, Gembloux Agrobio Tech, TERRA Teaching & Res Ctr, Gembloux, Belgium 42.Master Sch Carpentry & Cabinetmaking, Gleusdorfer Str 14, D-96106 Ebern, Germany 43.Enquist, Brian J.] Univ Arizona, Dept Ecol & Evolutionary Biol, Tucson, AZ 85721 USA 44.Enquist, Brian J.] Santa Fe Inst, 1399 Hyde Pk Rd, Santa Fe, NM 87501 USA 45.Univ Joinville Reg Univ, Dept Biol Sci, BR-89219710 Joinville, SC, Brazil 46.Reg Univ Blumenau FURB, Postgrad Program Forestry, BR-89030000 Blumenau, SC, Brazil 47.UR Forets & Soc CIRAD, Campus Baillarguet TA C-22E, F-34398 Montpellier 5, France 48.ULiege, Gest Ressources Forestieres Gembloux AgroBio Tech, Passage Deportes 2, B-5030 Gembloux, Belgium 49.CCT CONICET Mendoza, IANIGLA, Lab Dendrocronol & Hist Ambiental, Ave Ruiz Leal S-N,Parque Gral San Martin,CC 330, RA-5500 Mendoza, Argentina 50.Gottingen Univ, Dept Crop Sci Trop Plant Prod & Agr Syst Modellin, Grisebachstr 6, D-37077 Gottingen, Germany 51.Finnegan, Patrick M.] Univ Western Australia, Sch Biol Sci, Perth, WA 6009, Australia 52.Francisco, Kainana S.] USDA Forest Serv, Inst Pacific Isl Forestry, Pacific Southwest Res Stn, Hilo, HI USA 53.Galvao, Franklin; Marcon, Amanda K.] Univ Fed Parana, Dept Forest Sci, Curitiba, PR, Brazil 54.Giraldo, Jorge A.] Fac Ingn Tecnol Antioquia, Medellin, Colombia 55.Univ Fed Lavras, Programa Posgrad Agr Fisiol Vegetal, Dept Biol, Inst Ciencias Nat, BR-7203202 Lavras, MG, Brazil 56.Flanders Heritage Agcy, Havenlaan 88 Box 5, B-1000 Brussels, Belgium 57.Univ Idaho, Dept Earth & Spatial Sci, Moscow, ID USA 58.German Archaeol Inst DAI, Dept Nat Sci, D-14195 Berlin, Germany 59.Humboldt Univ, Dept Geog, D-12489 Berlin, Germany 60.GFZ German Res Ctr Geosci, D-14473 Potsdam, Germany 61.Univ Ghent, Fac Biosci Engn, Dept Environm, Lab Wood Technol UGent Woodlab, Ghent, Belgium 62.Shahjalal Univ Sci & Technol, Dept Forestry & Environm Sci, Sylhet 3114, Bangladesh 63.Washington State Univ, Sch Biol Sci, POB 644236, Pullman, WA 99164 USA 64.Czech Univ Life Sci Prague, Fac Forestry & Wood Sci, Prague, Czech Republic 65.US Fish & Wildlife Serv, Reg 2,500 Gold Ave SW,POB 1306, Albuquerque, NM 87103 USA 66.Nicolaus Copernicus Univ, Fac Biol & Vet Sci, Dept Ecol & Biogeog, Lwowska 1, PL-87100 Torun, Poland 67.Nicolaus Copernicus Univ, Ctr Climate Change Res, Ul Lwowska 1, PL-87100 Torun, Poland 68.Inst Nacl Innovac Agr, Programa Nacl Invest Forestal, Hualahoyo Km 8, Huancayo, Peru 69.Joshua Leffler, A.] South Dakota State Univ, Dept Nat Resource Management, Brookings, SD USA 70.Swansea Univ, Dept Geog, Singleton Pk, Swansea SA2 8PP, W Glam, Wales 71.Fed Univ Mato Grosso UFMT, Fac Agron & Anim Sci, Dept Soils & Rural Engn, Cuiaba, MG, Brazil 72.Univ Fed Parana, Dept Anim Sci, BR-80035050 Curitiba, PR, Brazil 73.Univ Tras Os Montes & Alto Douro, CITAB Dept Forestry Sci & Landscape CIFAP, P-5000801 Vila Real, Portugal 74.Manzanedo, Ruben D.] Swiss Fed Inst Technol, Inst Integrat Biol, D USYS, Plant Ecol, CH-8006 Zurich, Switzerland 75.Manzanedo, Ruben D.] Univ Bern, Inst Plant Sci IPS, CH-3013 Bern, Switzerland 76.Maxwell, Justin T.] Indiana Univ, Dept Geog, Bloomington, IN USA 77.Mendivelso, Hooz A.] Univ Pedag & Tecnol Colombia UPTC, Escuela Ciencias Biol, Ave Cent Norte 39-115, Tunja, Colombia 78.Mendoza-Villa, Omar N.] Univ Autonoma Queretaro, Fac Ciencias Nat, Ave Ciencias S-N Juriquilla, Queretaro 76230, Queretaro, Mexico 79.Fed Univ Sergipe UFS, Grad Program Ecol & Conservat, Sao Cristovao, Sergipe, Brazil 80.Brazilian Agr Res Corp Embrapa, Embrapa Amazonia Ocidental, BR-69010970 Manaus, Amazonas, Brazil 81.IHE Delft, POB 3015, NL-2601 DA Delft, Netherlands 82.Vrije Univ Amsterdam, Boelelaan 1085, NL-1081 HV Amsterdam, Netherlands 83.Univ Nacl Colombia, Posgrado Bosques & Conservac Ambiental, Medellin, Colombia 84.Univ Guadalajara, Ctr Univ Ciencias Biol & Agr, Zapopan 45200, Jalisco, Mexico 85.Univ Coimbra, Fac Sci & Technol, Dept Life Sci, Ctr Funct Ecol, Coimbra, Portugal 86.Natl Sci & Technol Dev Agcy, Natl Biobank Thailand, Pathum Thani 12120, Thailand 87.Nogueira, Francisco de Carvalho, Jr.] Fed Inst Sergipe IFS, Lab Ecol & Dendrol, BR-49100000 Sao Cristovao, Sergipe, Brazil 88.Univ Vale Rio dos Sinos UNISINOS, Plant Ecol Lab, Ave Unisinos 950, BR-93022750 Sao Leopoldo, RS, Brazil 89.Inst Biodiversa, Porto Alegre, RS, Brazil 90.Univ Sao Paulo, Nucl Energy Agr, Ave Centenario,303 Sao Dimas, BR-13416000 Piracicaba, SP, Brazil 91.Fed Univ Mato Grosso UFMT, Inst Biosci, Dept Bot & Ecol, Cuiaba, MG, Brazil 92.Columbia Univ, Tree Ring Lab, Lamont Doherty Earth Observ, 61 Route 9W, Palisades, NY 10964 USA 93.Univ Autonoma Gabriel Rene Moreno, Fac Ciencias Agr, Carrera Ingn Forestal, Km 9 Norte, Santa Cruz, CA, Bolivia 94.Univ Santiago Compostela, Dept Botan, BIOAPLIC, EPSE, Campus Terra, Lugo 27002, Spain 95.Colegio Frontera, Dept Soc Cultura, San Cristobal de las Casa, Chiapas, Mexico 96.Univ Nacl Toribio Rodriguez Mendoza Amazonas, Escuela Profes Ingn Forestal, Calle Higos Urco 342, Chachapoyas, Peru 97.Univ Nacl Loja, Lab Dendrocronol, Carrera Ingn Forestal, Loja 110101, Ecuador 98.Univ Calif Santa Cruz, Dept Environm Studies, Santa Cruz, CA USA 99.Univ Cauca, Fac Ciencias Agr, Popayan, Colombia 100.Univ Mayor, Fac Ciencias, Escuela Ingn Forestal, Hemera Ctr Observ Tierra, Santiago, Chile 101.Minist Publ Estado Mato Grosso, Ctr Apoio Tecn Execucao Ambiental, Cuiaba, MG, Brazil 102.Ctr Invest Reg Pacifico Ctr Campo, Inst Nacl Invest Forest Agr & Pecuarias INIFAP, Ctr Altos De Jalisco, Jalisco, Mexico 103.Univ Pablo Olavide, Dept Sistemas Fisicos Quim & Nat, DendrOlavide, Crta Utrera Km 1, Seville 41013, Spain 104.Sass-Klaassen, Ute; Zuidema, Pieter A.] Wageningen Univ, Forest Ecol & Forest Management Grp, Wageningen, Netherlands 105.Hall Larenstein Univ Appl Sci, Forest & Nat Management, Velp, Netherlands 106.Natl Inst Amazon Res, Ave Andre Araujo 2-936, BR-69067375 Manaus, Amazonas, Brazil 107.Silva, Lucas C. R.] Univ Oregon, Inst Ecol & Evolut, Dept Biol, Environm Studies, Eugene, OR 97403 USA 108.Free Univ Berlin, Dept Earth Sci, Malteserstr 74-100, D-12249 Berlin, Germany 109.Univ Autonoma Tamaulipas, Inst Ecol Aplicada, Ave Div Golfo 356, Victoria 87020, Tamaulipas, Mexico 110.Sousa, Luciana K. V. S.] Fed Univ Western Para UFOPA, Inst Biodivers & Forests, Santarem, PA 68040 USA 111.Speer, James H.] Indiana State Univ, Dept Earth & Environm Syst, Sci 159E, Terre Haute, IN 47809 USA 112.Therrell, Matthew D.] Univ Alabama, Dept Geog, Tuscaloosa, AL USA 113.Asociac ANDINUS, Programa Invest Ecol & Biodiversidad, Calle Miguel Grau 370, Huancayo, Junin, Peru 114.Torbenson, Max C. A.] Johannes Gutenberg Univ Mainz, Dept Geog, Mainz, Germany 115.Chulalongkorn Univ, Dept Environm Sci, Fac Sci, Bangkok 10330, Thailand 116.Chulalongkorn Univ, Water Sci & Technol Sustainable Environm Res Unit, Bangkok 10330, Thailand 117.Univ Nacl Autonoma Mexico, Inst Geog, Ciudad Univ, Mexico City 04510, DF, Mexico 118.Velazquez-Perez, Adin H.] Colegio Postgrad, Fac Ciencias Forest, Montecillos, Texcoco, Mexico 119.Univ OHiggins, Inst Ciencias Agroalimentarias Anim & Ambient ICA, San Fernando, Chile 120.Calif State Univ San Marcos CSUSM, Dept Biol Sci, San Marcos, TX USA 121.Delft Univ Technol, Fac Civil Engn & Geosci, Delft, Netherlands 122.Fontys Univ Appl Sci, Sch Teacher Training Secondary Educ Tilburg, Tilburg, Netherlands 123.Zavaleta, Erika S.] Univ Calif Santa Cruz, Dept Ecol & Evolutionary Biol, Santa Cruz, CA USA 124.Addis Ababa Univ, Sch Earth Sci, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia 125.Univ Maine, Sch Biol & Ecol, Orono, ME 04469 USA |
| Recommended Citation GB/T 7714 | Groenendijk, Peter,Babst, Flurin,Trouet, Valerie,et al. The importance of tropical tree-ring chronologies for global change research[J]. QUATERNARY SCIENCE REVIEWS,2025,355(x):-. |
| APA | Groenendijk, Peter.,Babst, Flurin.,Trouet, Valerie.,Fan, Ze-Xin.,Granato-Souza, Daniela.,...&Zuidema, Pieter A..(2025).The importance of tropical tree-ring chronologies for global change research.QUATERNARY SCIENCE REVIEWS,355(x),-. |
| MLA | Groenendijk, Peter,et al."The importance of tropical tree-ring chronologies for global change research".QUATERNARY SCIENCE REVIEWS 355.x(2025):-. |
| Files in This Item: | Download All | |||||
| File Name/Size | DocType | Version | Access | License | ||
| The importance of tr（7176KB） | 期刊论文 | 出版稿 | 开放获取 | CC BY-NC-SA | View Download | |
Items in the repository are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.
Edit Comment